The Port Byron High School was dedicated on Tuesday, January 16, 1900. It replaced the Port Byron Free Academy that was lost to fire in November 1898 at this same location. The architect was C. E. Crandall of Rochester, NY. The building was heated and ventilated with a Smeed-Norcot heating system and had running water on both floors. The Smeed Heating System was widely used in schools and other public buildings, its furnace generated heat by heating air. The building cost "nearly $16,500.00" (equivalent to "nearly" $440,000.00 based on 2009 CPI). The structure was described as housing 450 pupils, consisting of two floors with basement, six large study rooms, a laboratory, library and multiple recitation rooms.
Many will be surprised to learn that some pupils from Brutus attended our school here. In our early history, we were a progressive place. Woman started to serve on our Board of Education in the year 1890, before woman even had the right to vote. Helen Hadger Root was a teacher and among the first woman to serve on the school board. Her husband William H. Root a past Board of Education Member was present when both the Free Academy as well as the High School was dedicated.